I knew I didn't want a large quilt (it came in 2 sizes - large, and really large :) ). So, following Bonnie's advice, I made about 1/2 the blocks. Then, we are supposed to figure out what we want in the end, and make any additional blocks required to get there. Great idea! So I made "about" 1/2 - cut a few strips, made the segments it would make, and stopped there - no sense having 1/2 a strip cut and not used.
In the end, I had 12 of one block, and 8 of the other. 12 & 12 would have been perfect. I tried - really I did. As I sewed those 20 blocks together, I gave myself pep talks about cutting the remaining bits to make the missing blocks. I was also missing a bunch of border pieces (1/2 a quilt takes way more than 1/2 a border). But ... the missing pieces are all tri-recs. I have discovered a deep-seated hatred of tri-recs. Even though the tri-rec blocks were actually the easiest to assemble at the final stage, I just *really* don't want to cut more of them And piece more of them. 30 orange tri-recs, and 8 neutral ones - it doesn't seems like that much, but I just can't talk myself into it.
It doesn't help that I really don't like my colours. Bonnie's quilt is beautiful. But I don't really like scrappy. So I decided to do this one non-scrappy, because that worked so well for my Easy Street last year. But now that it's done, I really don't like the way the colours are playing. I think they're too dark - it needs more value changes in there. But I was browsing Bonnie's linky party and saw a post that didn't look like Bonnie's quilt. I hopped over there, and learned about some alternate layouts for this quilt.
So, I took my 20 blocks, and started playing.
I found lots of layouts that might look fine - if they were actually finished. But I don't haveenough blocks to go around, and that's how I got here in the first place.
How hard can this be? 20 blocks makes a 4x5 layout, which makes a 36x45" quilt before borders. I can make that work as a donation quilt, if only the blocks would play nice.
Getting better.
But maybe this one is best.
A quick count of border blocks, and a redesign there too. And maybe my celtic solstice will actually see completion.
Drop by Judy's blog for more design walls today.
Your redesign looks really nice.
ReplyDeleteI like the medallion effect -- especially the layout on the left, photo under "if only the blocks would play nice" -- but I understand your reluctance to make any more blocks. What begins as a fun and intriguing challenge can become a slog.
ReplyDeleteI love the one you choose...your quilt is amazing.
ReplyDeleteI agree-I like the one you like best. It has the most "balance." :) Good luck getting it done!
ReplyDelete-Lindsey {Inspiring Creations}
I am with you on the difficulty of doing Bonnie's quilts: lots of little pieces, odd cuts (tri rex) and way too many units and blocks. I am going to try to make the large quilt but I am going to take my time. make units for a while and then make blocks. I pretty much have decided against the tri-rex border as I don't really like it. Love your layout idea.
ReplyDeleteThere sure are a lot of Celtic Solstices out there and yours is one of the best ones. Love that outer border.
ReplyDeleteIt looks great - I am still at the early stages of making parts. I plan to make it queen sized but that will be a lot of blocks. I like your final layout.
ReplyDeleteoh what fun, all the different possibilities. I think I could do that all day, well as long as there's design wall. Love the look with the different borders.
ReplyDelete